I've decided to update my list. And I'll try to analyze it objectively this time rather than just from my perspective. As promised earlier today.
Old list:
katCrusader
SiX
Ultor
Toon
JTc
Lawliet
SweedyGonzales
Flath
Blaze
NumBle
New list:Quote:
katCrusader
SiX
Ultor
Toon:
JTc
Lawliet
SweedyGonzales
Flath
Blaze
NumBle
SiX:- Me making enemies out of the majority of you all, rather than focusing on one or two targets at most. I know that those I suspect aren't necessarily Mafia. They may as well be Town Members. But you see, I'm willing to make you vote me out of self preservation if you find it needed. I'm making my thoughts said even if it means ya'll be lynching or shooting me dead. Do you honestly think a Mafia or SK would risk their lives by accusing 7 players in the game? I think not. Because the more you accuse, the more will accuse you in turn. It's kind of like digging your own grave (I'll continue this argument later with Sweedy), something I don't mind doing as a Villager.
- Me taking on the role as the Town leader and promoting discussion and actions. Rather than giving in to idleness, I've decided to promote discussion by sharing my list of suspects with all of you. And indeed, every topic of discussion is currently surrounded around me and my list. And my penis vibes of course. This means I put myself in the spotlight to ensure that the Town members gets more active.
- My activity. This is mostly directed to you, Ultor. Having argued that you are a Town Member because of your active plays, it would be quite hypocritical of you not to give me the benefit of the doubt.
- Taking what Donald Dump (confirmed dead villager) stated into account here:
viewtopic.php?p=482827#p482827. This may not be a very strong argument on its own, but should be looked at from a larger perspective. For indeed, nothing stated there is so "secret" that I wouldn't have published it as a Mafia or Serial Killer.
With the above in mind, and taking into account our current circumstances, there's none better than me to trust right now. Those who want me gone are the Mafia and potentially the Serial Killer, with the remaining few Villagers just jumping on the bandwagon. If we want to have even the slightest chance of winning we have to unite under the Sweedygonzales bandwagon and seek his death. The worst thing you as a Villager can do right now is to have me lynched.
NumBle:- He revealed what Donald Dump said here:
viewtopic.php?p=482827#p482827. This means that Donald Dump (confirmed dead villager) suspected me and wanted to confirm my alignment through my actions. Thus he trusted Numble as a Town Member.
- He, like me and Ultor, have proven to be quite active. As such at least you Ultor, should give him a "+" in the book.
- Generally penis vibes about him being a Town Member, based on our discussions about who to lynch.
Flath:- Quoting SweedyGonzales (I'll get back to it later): "Flath hasn't said quite enough to make me think he is a villager. But that is mostly a hunch."
Blaze:- I beg to differ with what Emziek said before. While it's true that Blaze had a sense of self preservation afterwards (about not being lynched), that's not what I referred to when defending him. Rather, while Blaze don't want to be lynched, just like most WW players, he doesn't mind that "stupid jackass" act often seen in Villagers. I'm quite sure jTc knows what I'm speaking of, since Blaze acted just like he typically does while being a Town Member.
Ultor:- As he himself stated, he is active (or at least was the last few days). As such, just as he himself stated, I'm willing to give him a "+" in the book.
-
Ultor wrote:
I'm pretty sure others have figured out that I'm a villager by now (if you have objections please present yourself).
viewtopic.php?p=482428#p482428 he has the same attitude he also had in a previous game not too long ago when he said something along with: Anyone who hasn't realized I'm a confirmed Villager by now is stupid. And that time he was a Villager. I'm simply feeling the Penis vibes of him being capable of genuinely keeping up his attitude, since he's confident being a Villager, and doesn't mind projecting that outwards.
- Ultor is just being Ultor. While I've reasons to suspect him, it doesn't overweight the probability of him being a Villager. At least I don't want to risk it by lynching him just yet when there are better targets.
katCrusader:- The reasons remain. I've difficulty reading him due to his contributions, or perhaps lack of contributions, to the game. But he might be the Serial Killer or the last unknown Villager. The reasons for this is because I don't read him as being aligned with the Mafia, keeping his support for killing Dee Dee in mind.
viewtopic.php?p=482687#p482687Toon:- Your lack of general contributions to the game seems more like a Mafia member wishing for nothing to happen. Besides, that penis vibe list of yours doesn't seem very serious, since it's basically mine colored the opposite way (green<>red).
- Sweedy's reference to Flath: "Flath hasn't said quite enough to make me think he is a villager. But that is mostly a hunch."
Honestly speaking, neither you or jTc on the list have either. Or Lawliet for that matter. All 4 of you (Toon, jTc, Lawliet and Sweedy) can't be a Mafia. But since he's my prime suspect and since he didn't refer to you, it gives cause for suspicion. But you are still in the safer zone, for now.
- Right now 4 / 10 players are leaning towards being town (Me, Numble, Flath and Blaze) and if I was to add Ultor and Kat to that, it would make 6 / 6 / 10 Villagers. As such you'd be one of the 4 evil ones (SK, Thug, Godfather and Don). I'm only willing to bet on you being a Town Member if it means either Kat or Ultor is not. Most likely Kat.
Lawliet:- The beholder of your role prior to you coming in hasn't done anything to help the Town. And right now 4 / 10 players are leaning towards being town (Me, Numble, Flath and Blaze) and if I was to add Ultor to that, it would make 5 / 6 / 10 Villagers. As such, probability is that you are one of the 4 evil ones (SK, Thug, Godfather and Don).
- Sweedy's reference to Flath: "Flath hasn't said quite enough to make me think he is a villager. But that is mostly a hunch."
Honestly speaking, neither you or jTc on the list have either. Or Toon for that matter. All 4 of you (Toon, jTc, Lawliet and Sweedy) can't be a Mafia. But since he's my prime suspect and since he didn't refer to you, it gives cause for suspicion.
JTc:- Your statement: ""evil vibes", how about we get evidence instead of using our penis to feel vibes?" Right now we don't have any evidence to go by. And saying "Proof?" is the typical response from a Mafia being accused. Because right now, unless you provide better clues than my penis vibes, it means my penis vibes are the best we have to go by. As such, rather than proposing your own solution, you seek to stagnate the Town's progress by arguing that if there's no proof, nothing should be done. You basically want to waste time, something the Village does not have. As such you're most #2 most suspected person.
- Sweedy's reference to Flath: "Flath hasn't said quite enough to make me think he is a villager. But that is mostly a hunch."
Honestly speaking, neither you or Toon on the list have either. Or Lawliet for that matter. All 4 of you (Toon, jTc, Lawliet and Sweedy) can't be a Mafia. But since he's my prime suspect and since he didn't refer to you, it gives cause for suspicion.
SweedyGonzales:SweedyGonzales wrote:
[Vote SiX]
Just a counter vote for now till he puts away his vibrator and says something meaningful.
Flath hasn't said quite enough to make me think he is a villager. But that is mostly a hunch.
- Right now we don't have any evidence to go by. And trying to dismiss my message as not meaningful is the typical response from a Mafia being accused. Because right now, unless you provide better clues than my penis vibes, it means my penis vibes are the best we have. As such, rather than proposing your own solution, you seek to stagnate the Town's progress.
- By suspecting Flath, my take is that you direct your attention to one of those on my "red list". Because if both you and Flath are colored red, it shouldn't matter who of you I choose to lynch, right? Well, that's kind of what gave you away. You only targeted Flath, which means he's not a Mafia member (and the reason as to why I view him as a town member).
- You chose only to target 1 player. Sure you would suspect more than 1 person as a Villager. But you don't want to make too many enemies. And in addition to this, you decided to vote me, despite suspecting Flath.
To make a rough draft this is what I believe:
Mafia: Sweedy, jTc and Lawliet
Serial Killer: Katcrusader
Town: Six, NumBle, Flath, Blaze, Ultor and Toon.
If this is true, it means that all 10 slots are filled. And as such, I encourage everyone to vote Sweedy.