No, real counter claim

Imagine X is mafia
X gets asked to claim his role - not just alignment, but role.
X won't claim mafia roles (surprise!)
If he claims, e.g., doctor, while Y is the real doctor, Y will counterclaim. Should Y die and his alignment revealed, it will be clear that X is mafia. This makes Y safe from mafia kills. Should X die, then Y will be a confirmed villager which is good for the town.
If X claims vanillager, then other vanillagers might not even get asked to counterclaim, as it would be nearly impossible to gain any info from that massive vanilla counterclaim. Some wouldn't even counterclaim, some mafia maybe would...

Cause donald is the kind of guy who is bad at keeping secrets. If he is a role, It is not mafia, It probably is Doctor or Serial Killer. Im sure tho Flath, Toon and Maki beeing mafia. (A bit unsure of kat but I put him there for beeing most suspicious). I just have a Blazefeeling

Voting me (Cause obv i claim vanilla coconut villagier) and JTc is really a bad choice imo. Seeing JTc have nothing to lose and acts like a random fuck this game lol meaning he is probably a villager.

I will vote toon with Ultor and lets see how that works out. [Vote Toon]

P.s Stfu Donald i know youre the Doc or Serial killer.

No shit, Sherlock. If you're dead, mafia can't kill you.

Y is safe from makia kills because if he dies X will be revealed to be mafia

Hello.

Given that there are some newer players in this game (which is great to see), I have been given permission to assist, if anyone is crazy enough to go to someone who hasn't played for months for advice. I will be neutral and will not share information between players. I am able to work on rules issues or logic, although I will not apply the later beyond general situations (no asking me if I think <player> is mafia/a PR, for example).

I am cml on steam, or you can message me.
If adding me on steam, please let me know where I know you from.
http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198007601898/

Good luck, all.

Hi, nice to meet you :)

aye

So according to your deductions, I'll be shot by the mafia?

Switching my vote to [vote Blaze] because of this post viewtopic.php?p=482092#p482092. It serves no purpose to the village except major confusion as we have new players (possibly with a PR) who can easily be influenced by his post. There is also that case of him being the doctor and he wanted to manipulate the mafia into shooting the cop who he will be protecting- which is unlikely.

whats with the triple post ultor and what the fuck blaze?

Oh shit, he's on to me! I better change my vote
On a more serious note tho :p

Do you have any evidence? R1 is quite early to be sure that 3 people are mafia. Also, a claim of vanillager is a reaaaaally shitty reason not to vote someone >.>
[vote Blaze]

You guys never fucking learn that Im almost never mafia. Check old games for proof. Even if i were then I wouldnt even draw this much attention obviously. This is stupid [Vote Blaze]

Watch how half my claims are true at the end of the game

That's called a coin flip, otherwise known as the average for just guessing :p