my thoughts on everyone
pls correct me if I got anything wrong
(assassin) - no DMs, you were killed by a random nightkill from a SS member who forgot to submit a target
(merchant) - singlehandedly infiltrated both SS and DF. you helped me enormously to get my bearings in this game. We had an information exchange from R1 onward to which I think I contributed the lesser part, based on the agreement that we would not use this information against each other, and we never did, despite our realms being opposed to each other. You helped me not get lynched R1, I could've backstabbed you R2 to save Blaze and didn't (and tbh I still don't quite understand why). You wanted Ultor's realm and TD to lose, and I'm happy to say they did. 10/10 could not have done it without you
(wizard) - overeager with the doom, why? you betrayed your realm to me on 6/18 and then got modkilled 2 days later
(wizard) - the cards were stacked against you when you subbed in. Your tactic of "reduce to two players" turned BFrost from early-game threat into a mid- to late-game ally/threat, unfortunately your realm suffer a triple hit at that point and died. We had a good strategy talk. I wonder if you thought I told you our real disparity, and whom you told it to.
(physician) - tried to contact you, couldn't, sorry you didn't have time to play properly
(physician) - you got confused into claiming your realm and helped me not get lynched. we never talked much after you subbed back in for Patrick
(wizard) - we had a nice talk and I never knew your realm then. Would have enjoyed you having more time to spend on this game, definitely don't deserve to be listed on the "wall of shame" as you yourself asked to be replaced. Sometimes RL gets in the way.
(knight) - turned form being my "go-to" lynch in the morning into the late-game ally that TD needed, best possible ending IMO 10/10 would win with you again.
We might have talked a lot more, but especially lately the times when we could seemed to always be 3am for one of us, and you played your cards very close to your chest earlier. You put up with a lot from me. Did you know that Mystic had cursed Mmage as well as you? I was never sure if you were waiting for me to admit to it. Talking to you is often difficult for me, but always enjoyable.
/ Capage (merchant) - I found you as the lone disconnected SS member, you were my proof that SS had been infected (I knew before from werty, but now I could actually use the information). You're pleasant to chat with, almost as in over your head as I was on my first game here, would love to see what you can do once you get adjusted. Also, yay, someone from my own time zone!
(assassin) - it seems I have to apologize to you after every game. I should have realized you were actually our missing teammate and not called you out publicly, which caused you to get lynched. You never joined our team.
(knight) - tried to play an "honest" game, not giving false information or advice except when necessary to keep our secrets, with one or two exceptions, and of course I misunderstood more about the setup than I thought. I hope I was fun to play with, and I'm sure my R0 play made this game memorable anmd spicy right from the start.
(physician) - reliable active teammate, good support play, I enjoyed having you on our team
(wizard) - I hope I can repay your support when you get the limelight next time. your idea for our fake special saved my ass. It was good having your ideas, and having you to talk my ideas over with. In my defibrilation post-game rosterI wrote that I'd like to see more fo you playing, and my wish was granted. 10/10 would team up anytime
(wizard) - we had a fun chat together, pity that DF never saw TD as a viable ally
(knight) - your playstyle this game was designed to sow fear and distrust and even self-doubt, and I think you are doing it masterfully. I like interacting with you outside the game (e.g. over my setup), but in this game your playstyle rubbed me the wrong way, and I hope it's because it was designed to be. You said you had been disconnected from your realm until late, why?
(merchant) - I conducted diplomatic talks with DF through you after OddGuy died, competent and pleasant to talk to, but unfortunately our goals never aligned.
(assassin) - tried to contact, never replied, the public interactions verge into weird and wacky for some reason
(merchant) - after two games I still don't get your playstyle. We only had public interactions, and I definitely wouldn't have thought you a retribution, so Mission accomplished?
(knight) - you came to me in R0/R1 asking for help in finding your guys, and exchanged some information. You offered to ally over your disparity, which we only half believed in, and which we knew we wouldn't win with anyway, so the alliance was definitely going to be time-limited. After the Blaze lynch, it cooled off considerably, because you and ARSENIC didn't need our help any longer, so we never officially canceled. This is the one bit where I was less than honest (including saying in R3 that we were only asking 'round for alliance for show, because we really were seeking different allies), but then you guys lynched our guy, so I suspect this turn didn't come all that surprising to you. You could have been our late-game ally (and probably would have been) if you had helped bring SS and BF down.
(assassin) - we bonded over werty's predicament. You helped me get the player roster straight in a masterful move that got me to reveal Mystic was TD. Much of what I wrote about Lawliet applies to you as well, our operating goals were just too different to allow much cooperation (you really should've gone after SS early instead of DF), and before the ruling came down that our disparity would not trigger on a cult endgame, we were the only realm you couldn't actually win with.
(physician) - pleasant to chat with, hard to read, looking forward to play with you in the future. (SS aren't really overpowered, you just have to disable their Major early, which we could've done together but didn't. Told you so.
The 6th Realm
Hater & Rainboy
During the game, I was increasingly getting frustrated with the setup, since what you had written often didn't mean what I thought it meant, culminating in Hater first answering me that Armored would be refreshed by out Major and then not doing it. I protested, and he ultimately did (and then I never used it), but with all of the other issues (the missing "once" on the SS Major was public, and the stricken "permanently") I felt the other players weren't the only ones out to get me. Hence, me calling the hosts the "6th realm".
That said, you were incredibly active and supportive throughout the game; you managed to reasonably balance a setup with forty different skills (3 skills each on 5 standard roles, 1 special role skills and 4 skills for each faction = 40) that was fun to engage with and accommodated a wide choice of approaches to it. I just wish it had been written more precisely. ;-P
Thanks for hosting an amazing game, I know it can't be easy dealing with a prolific nitpicking player like me , but I hope I also contributed some to the fun you were hopefully having with this game.
Thank you, everyone!