[Town Win] Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

User avatar
Lawliet
Friend of the Community
Posts: 661
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2014 7:07 pm
Has thanked: 62 times
Been thanked: 33 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Lawliet »

There's the chance that both claims are real however. I hope it's not the case here..
User avatar
Numble
Posts: 1361
Joined: Tue Oct 01, 2013 7:37 pm
Has thanked: 23 times
Been thanked: 16 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Numble »

Lawliet wrote:There's the chance that both claims are real however. I hope it's not the case here..
That's why I'm saying: don't follow neither of them. They are at each others throat without decent reasoning.
You try to give your love away because you cannot bear its radiance, but you cannot separate it from yourself. To understand your fellow humans, you must understand why you give them your love. You must realize that hate is but a crime-ridden subdivision of love. You must reclaim what you never lost. You must take leave of your sanity, and yet be fully responsible for your actions.
Heart-Break
User avatar
Lawliet
Friend of the Community
Posts: 661
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2014 7:07 pm
Has thanked: 62 times
Been thanked: 33 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Lawliet »

Numble wrote:
Lawliet wrote:Let's say his deputy claim is real. where is the real Vigilante then ? he won't just sit there and watch the deputy getting lynched would he ?
I think it's quite obvious that Cruxell is a mafia now. I urge y'all to vote him.
The question isn't Where is the real vigilante. The question is "Do we have a vigilante?"
Either Vigilante or Trainee MUST counter-claim now no matter what the consequences are.
User avatar
Numble
Posts: 1361
Joined: Tue Oct 01, 2013 7:37 pm
Has thanked: 23 times
Been thanked: 16 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Numble »

Lawliet wrote:
Numble wrote:
Lawliet wrote:Let's say his deputy claim is real. where is the real Vigilante then ? he won't just sit there and watch the deputy getting lynched would he ?
I think it's quite obvious that Cruxell is a mafia now. I urge y'all to vote him.
The question isn't Where is the real vigilante. The question is "Do we have a vigilante?"
Either Vigilante or Trainee MUST counter-claim now no matter what the consequences are.
Let's remember that the mafia don't have a hitman, if what Grey said is true.

EDIT: And I'm confident enough that Ultor could shoot Kontra right now if the lynch doesn't go how he wants.

EDIT2: Also considering that they'll roleblock one, shoot the other it's highly recommendable NOT to claim.
You try to give your love away because you cannot bear its radiance, but you cannot separate it from yourself. To understand your fellow humans, you must understand why you give them your love. You must realize that hate is but a crime-ridden subdivision of love. You must reclaim what you never lost. You must take leave of your sanity, and yet be fully responsible for your actions.
Heart-Break
User avatar
Rainboy
Posts: 1923
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 4:38 pm
Location: Somewhere Over the Rainboy
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 41 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Rainboy »

Welp. I'm home! Looks like an eventful evening here...

Code: Select all

R2 Vote Tally:
Cruxell - 4 - HATEFUL, Lawliet, Styx, Six
HATEFUL - 3 - Cruxell, Larah, Dee Dee
Karn - 1 - Numble
No vote - 3 - Blaze, Karn, UnwaveringGrey
Cruxell lynched
Cruxell was the Deputy
SiX shot
SiX was the Vigilante
R3 has begun and will end at 9PM Eastern Time Friday


Well, that got messy fast. Good luck, guys!

Code: Select all

R3 Lynch Tally:
No Vote - 9 - Blaze, Numble, UnwaveringGrey, Lawliet, Dee Dee, Larah, Styx, Karn, HATEFUL
Sense? What fun is there in making sense...?
UnwaveringGrey
Posts: 183
Joined: Sun Jun 15, 2014 1:49 am
Location: New Jersey, 'Merica
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by UnwaveringGrey »

[Vote HATEFUL]

Code: Select all

Current vote tally:
HATEFUL - 1 - UnwaveringGrey
No lynch - 8 - Blaze, Lawliet, Maki, Dee Dee, Larah, Styx, Karn, HATEFUL
User avatar
Lawliet
Friend of the Community
Posts: 661
Joined: Mon Jun 30, 2014 7:07 pm
Has thanked: 62 times
Been thanked: 33 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Lawliet »

[vote HATEFUL]

Code: Select all

R3 Lynch Tally:
HATEFUL - 2 - UnwaveringGrey, Lawliet
No Vote - 7 - Blaze, Numble, Dee Dee, Larah, Styx, Karn, HATEFUL
Dee Dee

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Dee Dee »

[vote HATEFUL]

Code: Select all

R3 Lynch Tally:
HATEFUL - 3 - UnwaveringGrey, Lawliet, Dee Dee
No Vote - 6 - Blaze, Numble, Larah, Styx, Karn, HATEFUL
User avatar
Blaze
Posts: 4686
Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2010 1:50 pm
Location: In Your Toilet
Has thanked: 102 times
Been thanked: 35 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Blaze »

lol
Rainboy wrote: Cruxell lynched
Cruxell was the Deputy
SiX shot
SiX was the Vigilante
Image
Image
User avatar
Karn
Posts: 920
Joined: Thu Apr 19, 2012 9:55 pm
Has thanked: 9 times
Been thanked: 57 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Karn »

[vote HATEFUL]
This lynch is obvious, this round time should be used to identify another mafia. My doubts are on Lawliet and Numble. If the trainee got the deputy PR, I advice you to peek one of them.

Code: Select all

R3 Lynch Tally:
HATEFUL - 4 - UnwaveringGrey, Lawliet, Dee Dee , Karn
No Vote - 5 - Blaze, Numble, Larah, Styx, HATEFUL
Dee Dee

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Dee Dee »

@Anyone are all the shooting actions simultaneous?

__________________________________

Rainboy wrote: Cruxell lynched
Cruxell was the Deputy
SiX shot
SiX was the Vigilante
SiX wrote:[Vote Cruxell]
Unless SiX planned to shoot Ultor...

Image

__________________________________

Karn wrote:[vote HATEFUL]
This lynch is obvious, this round time should be used to identify another mafia. My doubts are on Lawliet and Numble. If the trainee got the deputy PR, I advice you to peek one of them.

Code: Select all

R3 Lynch Tally:
HATEFUL - 4 - UnwaveringGrey, Lawliet, Dee Dee , Karn
No Vote - 5 - Blaze, Numble, Larah, Styx, HATEFUL
LOOOOOOL RLY? If you read the first topic you will see there are 3 village power roles: deputy, doctor and vigilante/trainee. This means SiX had to choose one of them. So right now, WELCOME TO THE GAME, we only have the Doc.
User avatar
Karn
Posts: 920
Joined: Thu Apr 19, 2012 9:55 pm
Has thanked: 9 times
Been thanked: 57 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Karn »

LOOOOOOL RLY? If you read the first topic you will see there are 3 village power roles: deputy, doctor and vigilante/trainee. This means SiX had to choose one of them. So right now, WELCOME TO THE GAME, we only have the Doc.

Yes that was stupid, thought it was 4PRs.

Post about my doubts around numble incomming.
Last edited by Karn on Thu Feb 23, 2017 12:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Dee Dee

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Dee Dee »

Well make sure you don't just focus on Numble (even if your post will be about him). Try to get some perspective.

Also, was anybody roleblocked last night? Ultor maybe?
User avatar
Styx
Posts: 1023
Joined: Mon Aug 27, 2012 3:43 pm
Location: Norway
Has thanked: 74 times
Been thanked: 32 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Styx »

[vote HATEFUL]

Code: Select all

R3 Lynch Tally:
HATEFUL - 5 - UnwaveringGrey, Lawliet, Dee Dee, Karn, Styx
No Vote - 4 - Blaze, Numble, Larah, HATEFUL
Did this onnphone feel free to correct if wtong

EDIT I FIX
Last edited by Styx on Thu Feb 23, 2017 1:43 pm, edited 2 times in total.
I think we girls are bitches, even though I am one --------------
Image
Ultor
Posts: 604
Joined: Wed Dec 23, 2015 1:17 pm
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 16 times

Re: Mafia XXXV: Choices, Choices [MWF 9PM EST]

Post by Ultor »

What the actual fuck? How did this even happen, I was VERY certain hat Cruxell was a proxy since his counter-claim- it was so stupid claiming rather than Dee Dee as your R0 peek. Also, how the fuck did the mafia know about SiX? My answer would be- he was probably peeked at R1 and roleblocked this round which is why his shot did not happen.

For those who don't know, I was PROXY to SiX- gathering all information and reporting to him. Here are some logs:
Spoiler!
Never tell your password to anyone.
Tuesday, February 21, 2017
Ultor: yo
Ultor: u there
If team sucks I will feed: yeah
Ultor: have u looked at the game yet
If team sucks I will feed: somewhat
Ultor: ok and what do u think about grey claiming to be roleblocked
If team sucks I will feed: They might have a hitman and faked the existence of a consort; a spontaneous though
If team sucks I will feed: thought*
If team sucks I will feed: but
If team sucks I will feed: I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt
Ultor: its very likely hes telling the truth
Ultor: but there is no reason that allows us to trust him
If team sucks I will feed: I'll put him on my neutral/trust list for tyhe time being
Ultor: and what do u think about others, such as Larah
If team sucks I will feed: I think she's somewhat bitchy
Ultor: she is but i also started to think she doesnt want to be on the spotlight
Ultor: based on her response whenever i apply pressure on her
Ultor: but thats larah... i dont know if its actually a mafia trait or just her not being bothered to play the game properlyu so i guess shes village for now
If team sucks I will feed: hm
Ultor: anyway since grey's claim about being roleblocked
Ultor: it came to me the idea of me being a proxy for u to contact him
Ultor: or even better, the village directly
If team sucks I will feed: in what sense?
Ultor: so basically, in order to keep you safe, i claim as vig
If team sucks I will feed: Idk if they'd take ur vig claim seriously
Ultor: done it in many games, always worked
Ultor: as long as there is no counterclaim then it shouldnt be a problem
Ultor: unless ur not the real vig, then i dont see if there is a problem, assuming you trust me
If team sucks I will feed: I trusted you enough to claim it
If team sucks I will feed: so feel free to go with it if you like
Ultor: so should i claim to grey or in public?
If team sucks I will feed: up to you
Ultor: there is a chance of me being shot if i do it in public
Ultor: should we risk it?
If team sucks I will feed: ok but find a good reason why you claim it then
Ultor: mhm
Ultor: something like "ok guys im the vig, i was probably peeked but the mafia following my first post about role changes which is why i needed to claim- in order to survive and find out all the other PRs
Ultor: by the mafia*
If team sucks I will feed: you can do so yeah
Ultor: ok
Ultor: Okay so guys I'm the Vigilante . I was probably peeked by the mafia following my first post about role changes which gave away the fact that I had a PR. I know it was stupid at that time but it had to be done in order to prevent a very possible lynch made by Patrick. If you have a PR please claim to me so we can be 1 step ahead of the mafia.
Ultor: how about that
If team sucks I will feed: I like it
Ultor: posted
If team sucks I will feed: save logs with me btw
If team sucks I will feed: in case I am killed
Ultor: already done
If team sucks I will feed: alright
Spoiler!
Ultor: anyway have u looked at what dee dee and cruxell mentioned on the game
Ultor: after my claim
If team sucks I will feed: only dee dee
Ultor: Cruxell goes directly into beast mode
Ultor: and decides to lynch me lol
Ultor: He said he thinks everyone's roles necessarily changed. Since he was a vanillager in the first roll, the chances of him being mafia have increased to 50%. This is open for interpretation, but I believe his statement was explicit."
Ultor: how does that make sense
Ultor: "He said he thinks everyone's roles necessarily changed. Since he was a vanillager in the first roll, the chances of him being mafia have increased to 50%. This is open for interpretation, but I believe his statement was explicit."
Ultor: this is what ive been trying to aruge about with cruxell since r1
If team sucks I will feed: I'm not sure why he'd not give you the benefit of the doubt
If team sucks I will feed: Like you claimed vig
If team sucks I will feed: if you aren't, the real vig should shoot you
Ultor: as for Dee Dee's post
Ultor: this is my reply so far
Ultor:
Dee Dee wrote:Guys don't claim to him just yet. If the deputy has not peeked him yet, he should this round.
Sure, I don't mind being peeked. However, due to the mechanics of the game few things can go wrong:
1. The Deputy has been peeked by the mafia and is roleblocked every round (if there was no Hitman).
2. The existence of Framer would simply render me as being "Evil" to the Deputy when peeked.
3. Our doctor doesn't protect me and I end up getting shot- you lose a very effective ability to take out mafia.

I don't mind waiting for any counter-claims, and if I was a mafia, why on earth would I claim to be the vig who would most likely end up shooting me this round? It would be a very risky move coming from the mafia- unless there is Concert who has the vig under lockdown.
If team sucks I will feed: Since the mafia has a consort according to grey
If team sucks I will feed: you could confirm your role by shooting someone
Ultor: 1 sec let me finish writing up a reponse to cruxell
Ultor: ok i need u to look at this game
Ultor: http://www.neondragon.net/viewtopic.php?f=183&t=27054
Ultor: and if u could isolate donald dump's posts
Ultor: aka cruxell
Ultor: at that game i claimed doctor
Ultor: and he was mafia
Ultor: hes doing the same thing back when hes mafia, denying the claim, making some useless arugments
Ultor: as to what you said
If team sucks I will feed: I'll take it into account
If team sucks I will feed: will check it later
Ultor: sure
Ultor: also should I claim the shot before it happens?
Ultor: i dont see why not
If team sucks I will feed: feel free to do so
Ultor: lets assume that cruxell ends up being lynched
Ultor: who should we shoot?
Ultor: im most suspicious about Blaze
If team sucks I will feed: that's a good question
If team sucks I will feed: how long are the rounds?
Ultor: not sure
If team sucks I will feed: 48h or 24h?
Ultor: let me check
Ultor: PMs have been sent. R2 will end Wednesday at 9PM EST.
Ultor: so we got tmw
If team sucks I will feed: ok
Ultor: i guess we should wait before i claim the shot
If team sucks I will feed: yeah
Ultor: give them time to think about the counter-claims
Spoiler!
Never tell your password to anyone.
Wednesday, February 22, 2017
Ultor: also are you going to vote on anyone?
If team sucks I will feed: I will vote yes
Ultor: alright
If team sucks I will feed: discord channel?
Ultor: wat
If team sucks I will feed: wrong one
Ultor: ok
If team sucks I will feed: Talking to a dota2 guy at the same time :p
Ultor: ha multitasking
If team sucks I will feed: yup
Ultor: yooo
If team sucks I will feed: sup
Ultor: seen latest post?
If team sucks I will feed: I just did
Ultor: what do u think
If team sucks I will feed: I'll follow my original vibes'
Ultor: alright
Ultor: are you going to change vote or?
If team sucks I will feed: Posted
Ultor: okay
If team sucks I will feed: will add tally
If team sucks I will feed: It makes sense for him to fake claim deputy to try to get the vig killed as a last resort
Ultor: or he could be a proxy
Ultor: and his deputy peeked me, I was framed and told him to claim
If team sucks I will feed: Could be. But I think him being a Maf is more likely
Ultor: yeahj
Ultor: ill probably end up being lynched
Ultor: there are still 4 people left
Ultor: to vote
If team sucks I will feed: Hm
Ultor: blaze probably hates me and will vote agaisnt me
If team sucks I will feed: Lets see what they do.
Ultor: karn we know already..
Ultor: numble not sure and grey not sure
If team sucks I will feed: As for me, I really do have to start shooting people
Ultor: just careful not to shoot the wrong one
If team sucks I will feed: That will be difficult.
Ultor: blaze still havent replied even after my claim
Ultor: so thats a possible target
Ultor: numble not sure, i think hes village
Ultor: blaze afk probably a hidden mafia
Ultor: its more likely for dee dee to be a villager tho
Ultor: shes easily manipulated - there was 1 game when she was a mafia
Ultor: and Cruxell was a villager and he got her to reveal the fact she was a mafia
If team sucks I will feed: Ah
Ultor: i think that was either her first or second game
Ultor: they might be planning to switch votes just before round end?
If team sucks I will feed: Might be. But then I'll kill them tomorrow if you flip town.
Ultor: alright
If team sucks I will feed: If I live that is.
If team sucks I will feed: No vote - 4 - Numble, Blaze, Karn, UnwaveringGrey
Ultor: you should be able to, i never mentioned your name to anyone
If team sucks I will feed: I'll shoot 1 of these tonight
If team sucks I will feed: Assuming Cruxell will be lynched.
Ultor: why those?
If team sucks I will feed: Larah and dee dee can both easily be manipulated as you put it
Ultor: yeah
If team sucks I will feed: and I will bet on cruxell being lynched
Ultor: mhm
Ultor: yeah and id take out grey from the list
Ultor: maybe hes telling the truth about being roleblocked
If team sucks I will feed: I'm also concerned about Numble
Ultor: he still hasnt voted yet, but im confident hes village- thats his normal play style.
If team sucks I will feed: Indeed.
If team sucks I will feed: Why do you think Blaze will vote you?
Ultor: based on previous games
Ultor: always a troll
Ultor: ill show u a link
Ultor: he made a voice message
Ultor: because when we played that vampire game
Ultor: I was a vampire, and he was neutral and I got him to reveal one of the wolfs
Ultor: and he got angry so he made this voice message and held grudges ever since
Ultor: http://vocaroo.com/i/s1Ia8d7lwTlb
If team sucks I will feed: Oh yeah I heard of that
If team sucks I will feed: was a meme on discord
Ultor: yeah lol
I don't blame you for lynching me this round because his death would make so much sense. However, I want you to isolate my posts and find those hints I gave away for being a proxy especially this post: http://www.neondragon.net/viewtopic.php ... 91#p499691. Lawliet should be able to back me up on this one. So lynching me would end up with another 2 villagers DEAD (assuming that the doctor doesn't protect anyone) which would leave us with 4 villagers vs 3 mafia. Also I would like to point out that I never said anything to anyone about SiX - I don't get how the mafia found out he was the vig...
Post Reply

Return to “Finished Games”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 26 guests