Page 11 of 16

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 9:32 pm
by Ish
Lawliet wrote:
Interesting..
I wanna hear why you think I'm the medic and not actually a Doctor.. If you ask me It's very unlikely for the medic to claim Doc publicly since he's probably gonna get checked by the cop. Also, If somehow the 2 Docs are already in contact with each others that means the cop has to do nothing.. they would just vote him or use the OD to kill him.[/quote]

It's normally unlikely for the doctor to claim doctor so easily. If you are the doctor just gave mafia free information just to kill you, they wouldn't even need to use their shot on you, if you heal yourself this round, they can just easily use their medic to OD you...

Yeah you might get checked by the cop, but that's if you survive the night... which then your gamble pays off..
EDIT: Just red Sixs post above.

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 9:36 pm
by Konijn
!!!*-Leo-*!!! wrote:why does Gerty not accept my vote on Mafia guy Ultor???
GERTY is a little sick, I fixed him for now

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 9:42 pm
by Numble
Konijn wrote:
!!!*-Leo-*!!! wrote:why does Gerty not accept my vote on Mafia guy Ultor???
GERTY is a little sick, I fixed him for now
tummyache again?

On topic now:

@Ish, I think six explained it through his version of the hater wall;

@Leo(Ironic.. never though I'd see myself addressing my own name), I don't see why Ultor's gameplay completely reveals that he's mafia. Sure, he was alot more agressive on the last game, but that almost got him lynched. Maybe he's taking a more calm approach? I don't know;

@WaywardVole, I'd like to hear more coming from you. I don't want to put a spotlight right on top of you but, you've been mostly quiet and your posts aren't exactly contributing that much for the village. You pretty much just round up what's going on from time to time.

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 9:45 pm
by Lawliet
Ish wrote:
Lawliet wrote:
Interesting..
I wanna hear why you think I'm the medic and not actually a Doctor.. If you ask me It's very unlikely for the medic to claim Doc publicly since he's probably gonna get checked by the cop. Also, If somehow the 2 Docs are already in contact with each others that means the cop has to do nothing.. they would just vote him or use the OD to kill him.
It's normally unlikely for the doctor to claim doctor so easily. If you are the doctor just gave mafia free information just to kill you, they wouldn't even need to use their shot on you, if you heal yourself this round, they can just easily use their medic to OD you...

Yeah you might get checked by the cop, but that's if you survive the night... which then your gamble pays off..
EDIT: Just red Sixs post above.[/quote]
well well.. who knows if i'm gonna heal myself OR i'm just gonna let the medic take care of me :))
mind games ezpz

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 10:53 pm
by ZeRo#1
Konijn wrote:
!!!*-Leo-*!!! wrote:why does Gerty not accept my vote on Mafia guy Ultor???
GERTY is a little sick, I fixed him for now
ahahah okay thank you =)

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 11:07 pm
by Ultor
No but my thoughts are that Ultor is to quiet now..in the last game he was a villager (watcher) and he played very aggresiv or was more helpfull as a villager..for me he is a bit to much in the background now to get not seen as a mafia guy and as i said..that is not Ultor if i joke to him with words like "how you feel as Mafia this time" he wouldn´t only say "i wish and xD" he would try/do all in my opinion to convince me/all that he is not a Mafiosi...specially after i showed it in a post here (my thoughts on him) he would act more in game i think.

[vote Ultor]
First of all when you had a chat with me on steam I was actually busy which is why I responded with short answers. This previous game you speak of was my first game and I was spreading information all over the place which nearly got me killed as a watcher.

This is why I decided to take a more relaxed, thoughtful approach. I've also been really busy nowadays. Anyway, the fact that I responded to your "how you feel as Mafia this time" question with a "I wish" response was because I really wanted to try out being a mafia at this game, and not a normal villager (which is what I am).

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 11:18 pm
by SiX
It appears that Ish won't be lynched this round. The expected lynch is K0ntRa, which would in all likelihood turn up fatal for the Town. Hence I'll vote Sweedy instead.
With this I'm offline and I won't be online until the outcome of the round.

[Vote SweedyGonzales] (not day)

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2016 11:42 pm
by Apekiller
SiX wrote: Apekiller, at first, took K0ntRa in defense, which is fine. I did it too. But then, he moved the suspicion over to the afk ones. "Should we kill the afk ones?" was what was on his mind. If we assume that Apekiller is Mafia, then how would he profit from lynching someone who would likely get modkilled in the future? Well, he makes sure no suspicion would be put on his fellow Mafia team. In other words: if the Town is always voting the inactive ones, no suspicion will be put on the active ones. With this in mind, it's likely that Apekiller's Mafia teammates are active. Ish and Sweedy both fit this description. The fourth member? He may be inactive, I don't know. But at least the majority of the Mafia team is active. In addition to this, it would also make sure they are lynched before returning to actively participating in the game. In other words: kill them in their sleep. Basically town gets nothing out of lynching them.

...

Secondly, he was against K0ntRa's proposition of not having the Doctors healing each other, saying it was a flawed reasoning, while it in fact makes perfect sense. The Mafia wants the town to keep on healing.
It made less sense to me to lynch an active player than to lynch a player who has not (yet) contributed to the game in any way. True, it would have been better to suggest no lynch in that post, but I was at that point unaware that voting no lynch was a possibility. Keep in mind that this is my second WW game (excluding mini one hosted by K0ntRa in Spam section). I was indeed thinking it would be better to lynch an AFK player as opposed to a player who is actively contributing to the village.

I was of the opinion that having the doctors NOT act at all would not be a wise choice to make. I never said anything in specific about Doctors healing each other, what K0ntRa addressed was the Doctors using their powers overall. I was later convinced by your (SiX') post explaining why it was in fact good for the Doctors not to act in R1, if they did not know who the other Doctor was.

I'm going to [vote K0ntRa] (not day). The first reason for this is that I currently have not yet voted anything (Hospitalised R1), and I don't want to end up getting modkilled. Also, I find it kinda suspicious that K0ntRa pushed so hard against Sweedy based on a fairly weak bit of evidence. His follow-up reasoning also made little sense to me.

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2016 4:06 am
by HATER
round ended. Post will be up soon.

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2016 4:19 am
by HATER
K0ntra Lynched
K0ntra Died
K0nta was a Normal Villager (Miller)

Ish Overdosed
Ish Died
Ish was a Doctor

!!!*-Leo-*!!! Stabbed
!!!*-Leo-*!!! Survived

SiX shot
SiX died
SiX was a Normal Villager





[kill k0ntra, lynched]
[dusk]
[kill Ish, Overdosed]
[log !!!*-Leo-*!!!, Stabbed R2]
[kill SiX, shot]
[dawn]

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2016 4:47 am
by WaywardVole
Shit, apologies I missed the vote. (Dat Game of Thrones finale tho)


There was a pretty big bandwagon on K0ntRa and while some of them are probably random villagers, chances are the mafia team jumped on board. Combined with the fact that 2/3 of the people who voted for Sweedy this round ended up dead, he's not looking too good right now. I agreed with SiX awhile back that K0ntRa may have gone of half cocked with the accusations, but with the rate villagers are dropping, I'm going to take the chance.


Imma [vote Sweedy Gonzales] (unknown target).

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2016 4:52 am
by WaywardVole
Bonus post since it's late and I fucked up the last one.

[vote SweedyGonzales]

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2016 9:52 am
by ZeRo#1
What the hell is goin on???

I think we little villager group have not really more a chance to win this game.
4 Mafia Guys vs 6 Villagers.

It looks like that some villagers felt in the trap of the mafia guys and jumped on the Bandwagon to lynch K0ntra...so sad to see that.
Since you guys saw i got stabbed and survived (thank you Doc, good choice) im a trustworthy villager. All (real) villager pls think about all clearly and do all that we dont lose this game so fast. Feel free to pm me and work with me together.
Now we need to rethink who was the most hater of Kontra to get him lynched, why did it happen that Ish took the overdose and more.

Well to be honest to give up is not a choice of mine, but we are fucked thats my opinion...why you so evil Mafia guys :D

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2016 9:58 am
by ZeRo#1
Short thoughts of mine are:

Lawliet = Medic...thats why Ish died by an overduse.
Apekiller in my opinion Mafia guy his post doesn´t look for me that he tried this time to let the village town stay allive and he gave the last vote on Kontra...that Ultor don´t need to vote (hide his role, after Mafia guys spoke with him).
And atleast what Kontra tried to show that Sweedy should be definitely a Mafia guy. So my vote thoughts are Sweedy or Ultor, after i claimed Ultor is Mafia guy and maybe wasn´t wrong with that (got stabbed for that) i go for Ultor.
PS: Apekiller was hospitalized after the 1st round and now they didn´t tried to kill him again..hmmh suspect good way to hide his mafia position too...maybe he have an important mafia position.
Also the Mafia guys killed all active players, bcs of the fact that the others not really a target for them. That let me think too that the most active poster of this game Mafia guys and the others too quiet villagers that jumped on the BW.

[vote Ultor]

Re: Mafia XXIX: Defibrilation

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2016 10:57 am
by Lawliet
!!!*-Leo-*!!! wrote:Short thoughts of mine are:

Lawliet = Medic...thats why Ish died by an overduse.
Apekiller in my opinion Mafia guy his post doesn´t look for me that he tried this time to let the village town stay allive and he gave the last vote on Kontra...that Ultor don´t need to vote (hide his role, after Mafia guys spoke with him).
And atleast what Kontra tried to show that Sweedy should be definitely a Mafia guy. So my vote thoughts are Sweedy or Ultor, after i claimed Ultor is Mafia guy and maybe wasn´t wrong with that (got stabbed for that) i go for Ultor.
PS: Apekiller was hospitalized after the 1st round and now they didn´t tried to kill him again..hmmh suspect good way to hide his mafia position too...maybe he have an important mafia position.
Also the Mafia guys killed all active players, bcs of the fact that the others not really a target for them. That let me think too that the most active poster of this game Mafia guys and the others too quiet villagers that jumped on the BW.

[vote Ultor]
I'd love to know how you jumped to this conclusion.

Btw I'm just a normal villager.. my claim last round was to get the 2 Docs claim to me and connect them to each others. Now that Ish turned Doc the other one might think I'm an evil and that's why I'm posting this. and yeah none of the 2 claimed to me.. I hope Ish didn't get TKed.. I really hope not.