View unanswered posts | View active topics It is currently Fri Apr 19, 2019 9:25 am


Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#6 (ISO #1)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux)
[in]

Fri May 18, 2018 8:28 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#124 (ISO #2)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R1 ends 8 PM EDT Saturday
[vote Thierry Henry#CR7]
You're very quiet, we townies need some attention as well.

Fri May 25, 2018 9:20 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#168 (ISO #3)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R1 ends 8 PM EDT Saturday
[vote Emziek]
Changing my vote since Thierry seems to have quit the game.
Emziek, you may not be able to vote, but you can still contribute to the discussion.
I'd say that we should keep an eye closely on the Mystic-Romeo situation and see how it develops.
We cannot be certain if one of them is mafia or not, perhaps the mafia purposely claimed cop to one of them to discover if they have a power role.
Either Mystic or Romeo being night killed while a power role would defuse this situation.
We must continue to be careful and select a viable candidate for lynch. All this strife over the rapidly-changing vote makes me think that one of the proposed lynch targets may be a mafia.
Remember that they control a quarter of the vote, and will try to influence it if it seems unfavorable for them. On the other hand, if a townie is being led to the gallows, expect quietude from previously active players.
Code:
Mendel - 3 - Blaze, Mystic, Romeo
Romeo - 3 - Styx, JTc, Katika VS
Cruxell - 3 - Patrick, Numble, Lawliet
Blaze - 1 - Wertydoo
Emziek - 1 - Cruxell
wertydoo - 1 - Draichrog

Expected LHLV - Mendel

No vote - 2 - Thierry Henry#CR7, Mendel
Incapacitated - 2 - Emziek, Ultor


Sat May 26, 2018 10:44 am Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#213 (ISO #4)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R1 ends 8 PM EDT Saturday
It's nice that we've got a smart and helping discussion going on, but we also need to put pressure on the AFKs. If they're townies, they will stand idly and passively as we get massacred, and if they're mafia they have the best possible cover right now. They're not suspicious and are able to do whatever they want behind our backs.
Emziek has written a total of four game-related words. Emziek, you need to join in man.
Romeo wrote:
Numble wrote:
Draichrog wrote:
Draichrog wrote:
And leave Romeo alone too.

So wait.. tell me why are you standing up for Romeo when's claimed Mafia.

What the crap, Numble, have you not been here for the last like day? Been talking about this all day...I am not gonna explain anymore because I am dead anyways.

This is probably my last post.

This is what I have to say...going to talk about the probable next mafia play...This is what I think the mafia team would do...

1. Kill Draich which in this circumstance would tell us that the person who peeked Mystic is a mafia but at the same time our COP would be dead...

☆It is a possibility that mafia would kill Draich and he would turn out to be a mafia and the mafia would do it because Draich has caused them too much chaos and they are worried that he will expose them, but thats very rare..


2. Kill Mystic, so he doesn't speak up about who contacted him and therefore we know that Draich is villagealigned

My (potentially) last wish:

- Draich post the conversation that happened last between us...

My suspicion: Mendel, Lawliet and Patrick.

Why would the mafia kill Draichrog if he's one of them? That makes no sense to be honest.

With two village doctors in the game and the overdose mechanic, the mafia will likely target a low profile player thereby hoping that he will not be protected.

Anybody else noticed that the name of the game is misspelled :P ? Also, I'd say XLI would be more orthodox then XXXXI for 41.

Sat May 26, 2018 8:06 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#227 (ISO #5)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R1 ends 8 PM EDT Saturday
Emziek wrote:
Nah I'm good

Unfortunately, people will take this with humor, ignore common sense and not consider Emziek a potential threat. I implore you to see reason, either (1) he's village and will contribute nothing to the game, potentially harming us as well or (2) he's a mafia and has accomplished exactly what they all hope for: to subtly blend in with the crowd unnoticed.
I stand with my vote. Sarcasm, humor and joking will not win the game. HATER shared his thoughts on this too, in the OP:
HATER wrote:
I also expect each player to do their best to play for their team's win condition. Deliberately attempting to troll or sabotage your own team for no good strategic or tactical reason is unacceptable. I really hate that I have to say this as it should be common sense, but we've had problems in the past with it, so here I am.


Sat May 26, 2018 9:54 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#228 (ISO #6)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R1 ends 8 PM EDT Saturday
Blaze wrote:
Romeo wrote:
Do fish have memory at all?

https://www.amnh.org/learn-teach/young- ... you-think/
This study says yes, slow learners, but decent memory

Welp, I'm glad we got that sorted out.

Sat May 26, 2018 9:55 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#271 (ISO #7)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
1. Styx
2. Blaze
3. Mystic - Stabbed R1, Shot R1, Normal Villager
4. Cruxell
5. JTc
6. Numble
7. Romeo
8. Katika VS
9. Draichrog - Overdosed R1, Village Cop
10. Lawliet
11. Thierry Henry#CR7
12. Patrick
13. Emziek
14. Ultor - Lynched R1, Normal Villager
15. Wertydoo
16. Mendel

Remaining roles:
1x Cop (former deputy)
2x Doctor
5x Normal Villager

1x Don
1x Hitman (still has his shot)
1x Medic
1x Trainee

1x Serial Killer

Secondary roles:
Meth Addict (Ultor)
Tough
Miller

Sun May 27, 2018 11:02 am Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#282 (ISO #8)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
Mendel wrote:
Emziek wrote:
Conclusion: Numble & Blaze aren't the cereal killer

Well, I have my own theory on why the SK would target Mystic, but together, this does raise the likelyhood that Cruxell is the SK.

What? How on earth does the innocence of Numble and Blaze make me the Serial Killer?
Just trying to comprehend the meaning of these poetic words.

Sun May 27, 2018 1:06 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#285 (ISO #9)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
Patrick wrote:
Just starting from where we left yesterday before all the confusion in the end of the round. Step the fuck up Cruxell and share your thoughts with the rest of us.

You popped up randomly on discord last night after the round was over.

[vote Cruxell]

Code:
Mendel - 1 - Blaze
Cruxell - 2 - Patrick, Mendel
No vote - 10 - JTc, Numble, Lawliet, Cruxell, Romeo, Wertydoo. Styx, Katika VS, Thierry Henry#CR7, Emziek


@HATER, what is the status with Thierry's situation?


Edit: Just saw Mendel's vote. Updated the tally

When I saw this, my instincts told me that I could be the miller and you could've be a confidante of Hunie the cop, but then I remembered that he was eliminated before he could've peeked anybody, except for the R0 negative. Your first serious vote was on me, then as soon as you'd seen me on Discord you started putting pressure on me. And now again you're jumping on a bandwagon, accusing me of - what again? Being AFK? Mate, this is my ninth post. Niende.
You want somebody to share his thoughts with the players? How about you ask Thierry Henry or JTc with their ZERO and TWO game related posts, respectively.
Hence, the only possibilities left at the table are:
  • (1)You're mafia, I'm the miller and you have peeked me as the Serial Killer therefore you want to eliminate me out of the game. Through glibness and lying you are hoping to get the village to lynch me, and you will use the night kill on somebody else, perhaps a confirmed townie.
  • (2)You're throwing, feeding or trolling. Despite still having faith in humanity, seeing your overtly aggressive behavior towards me, it could be possible that for some reason you want specifically me out of the game. Good luck with that.
I'd say it's rather interesting that the mafia had chosen Patrick as the person who will advocate their wishes publicly to influence the target of the lynch. He is likely the Trainee, thus while the rest of the mafia is keeping low profile, Patrick is the one who will interfere with the village and corrupt the vote.
Lawliet has been Patrick's partner throughout the entire length of the game. Whenever one would vote, the other would help him. They would stick out for one another. They're providing each other support. Because of this, I'd say it's likely that Lawliet is the second most undesirable mafia role, the Medic, while Patrick has the arguably most useless role, the Trainee.
In other words guys, Patrick is a small fish, he does not have an important role and has little influence in the mafia domain. This is why they are instructing him to show aggressive, risky and compromising behavior. Lawliet is his follow-up, and will come in his aid. Just watch how Lawliet will write an op-ed about this.
So, we've deducted who the Medic and the Trainee are. The mafia clearly saw Medic as a more important role, and so do I, hence I will be voting on Lawliet first and Patrick second. If you guys deem that Trainee is a better role, you can vote Patrick, but I feel like this is the safest approach to take.
[vote Lawliet]

Sun May 27, 2018 1:35 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#286 (ISO #10)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
Updated Tally:
Code:
Mendel - 1 - Blaze
Cruxell - 2 - Patrick, Mendel
Lawliet - 1 - Cruxell
No vote - 10 - JTc, Numble, Lawliet, Romeo, Wertydoo. Styx, Katika VS, Thierry Henry#CR7, Emziek


Sun May 27, 2018 1:36 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#287 (ISO #11)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
It's important that we analyze the overdose mechanic and the playstyle of the Medic.
HATER wrote:
*This game, since there are 3 doctors total, invokes the Overdose mechanic: If a person is protected by more than one doctor in a single night, they will die.

As we all know, if a person is protected by more than 1 doctor or medic, they die. This left the mafia with two possible alternatives for how to utilize the Medic.
(1) He could've protected a fellow Mafia from the Serial Killer, but that would carry risks. What if a doctor protected the same guy and he died to overdose?, they thought.
(2) Protect a high-profile town member, a confirmed Power Role or somebody otherwise innocent, hoping that a village doctor will protect them too, but with a genuine hope to save them from death. It seems that he opted for this option.

We know the targets of the previous round of all healing roles of the game. Mystic, an asset to the town, was protected and as such he survived the SK stab. Funnily enough, he was also targeted and successfully night killed by the mafia. The mafia Medic would've never protected somebody who they were gonna attack, therefore what is clear is that one of the two Doctors protected Mystic.
Hunie died due to overdose meaning that two healing roles targeted him. As a Doctor saved Mystic, we're left with one Doctor and one Medic. So the Medic protected Hunie hoping to overdose him, which he succeeded in doing. The town Doctor healed Mystic as he genuinely tried to save him from a potential NK.

Protections of R1/R2:
Mystic - Doctor
HuniePop -Medic, Doctor

This reveals valuable information of the Mafia strategy - they will be targeting high-profile townies with the Medic, expecting that these townies will be protected and thus overdosed.
Doctors, do not protect distinguished townies. Protect insignificant ones to avoid OD.

----------------------------------------------------------

Mendel wrote:
Cruxell wrote:
Mendel wrote:
Emziek wrote:
Conclusion: Numble & Blaze aren't the cereal killer

Well, I have my own theory on why the SK would target Mystic, but together, this does raise the likelyhood that Cruxell is the SK.

What? How on earth does the innocence of Numble and Blaze make me the Serial Killer?
Just trying to comprehend the meaning of these poetic words.

it helps actually reading my post

Quote:
* Safest play for the SK is to park their vote elsewhere
* Surviving players not voting for either Romeo or Draichrog: Numble, Cruxell, Blaze, Romeo, (Thierry Henry)

* Romeo is innocent
* SK struck last night but Thierry resigned
* Numble and Blaze are probably not the SK (says Emziek)
* you are the only one left on the list
* you are most likely to be it
(it is not a guarantee, but if you wait for guarantees in mafia, you never lynch anyone)


What? Your logic is flawed. Why would the SK necessarily be among those who didn't vote for either Romeo or Draichrog? The SK could've voted for pretty much anyone, especially because he's got an extra vote.

----------------------------------------------------------

Guys, it's important to realize that we're in a bad situation now.

We're playing this 8v5, so in the worst case scenario that we lynch a townie which we most likely will do if we're not cautious, it will be a 5v5 next round. As soon as the SK dies, we will lose over parity.

I dare not call this a LiLo situation yet, but we must immediately begin to work on finding who the mafia are.

If we are too late, we will lose the game.

Luckily, we've found out that Patrick and Lawliet are mafia, so we should eliminate them as fast as possible.

Sun May 27, 2018 1:57 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#291 (ISO #12)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
@Mystic's informants

You need to step up.

We need more info about his plan and how it was executed.

If we receive no claims for this, sadly we can expect that Mystic sent it to two mafias.

So don't feel scared, share what you know with the rest of the group.

Does anybody else know why they're not talking?

Sun May 27, 2018 3:41 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#297 (ISO #13)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
>Speechless for 21 minutes
>As soon as we start accusing Lawliet he starts talking again, comes in Lawliet's defense
https://imgur.com/a/LN2kgUY
@Mafia, you must stop sacrificing only Patrick. Find somebody else to influence the vote.
Patrick wrote:
Blaze wrote:
Cruxell wrote:
Updated Tally:
Code:
Cruxell - 2 - Patrick, Mendel
Lawliet - 2 - Cruxell, Blaze
No vote - 10 - JTc, Numble, Lawliet, Romeo, Wertydoo. Styx, Katika VS, Thierry Henry#CR7, Emziek

Really, Im against both mendel and patrick. So im going to team up with crux cause i believe he is a villager more than they are
Blaze wrote:
Cruxell - mafia number 2. Why? Because of playstyle. Come on guys check it for fuck sake

Thinks Cruxell is mafia - decides to vote with him because he is against Mendel and me --> Votes Lawliet

Here we have it again. As soon as Lawliet was accused he's white knighting him. Clearly a pair of mafias.

Sun May 27, 2018 4:27 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#314 (ISO #14)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
Werty's post makes him somewhat more trustworthy, although it is entirely wrong. I highly doubt that the mafia would now switch their method of interference with the village by tasking Werty with standing up for Patrick and Lawliet. They already sent a probe in with Patrick, and he did not come off as suspicious so they can continue to use him. It might be that they're trying to get the heat off him for a while, but if they were, they would probably employ Lawliet to do what Werty did. Luckily, players such as Numble are beginning to see the bigger picture and draw parallels thereby understanding the association of Patrick and Lawliet. So perhaps they did indeed tell Patrick to keep his head down. We shall find out eventually.
Spoiler: show
HATER wrote:
wertydoo wrote:
HATERCan we do something to make life easier for Mendel regarding this? I have to admit that sometimes when I come home from being afk, I cannot be bothered to read multitudes of discord messages scattered all over the timestamps.

I'm at a bit of a loss as to what can be done here -- I could bar the use of communication outside the thread, but I really hate changing rules mid-game if I can help it (plus the last time anyone tried a no-pming game this community basically fucking rioted).

Apart from attempting to separate the regular neon spam from the actual mafia discussion, I'm not sure there's a whole lot else I can do from this position that doesn't change game balance (such as taking away discord communication about the game altogether).

I think the change has to come from players (especially players who have been very active on discord but not on the thread) that realize that while discord can be a convenient communication tool, it should not comprise the bulk of thei game-realted communication and if they intend to say something in discord there is a decent change it will not be seen by much of its target audience (which gives mafia an inherent advantage, because information that otherwise might be considered public can be hidden from some of the village, but if even 1 out of the 4 mafia see important information being shared in discord, the whole mafia team will soon know about it).

If you have any ideas on this matter, feel free to PM me. There is a potential fix below...

TARS Stuff:
[spoiler]I would love to institute a TARS logging feature for discord posts where every 15 minutes or so he sets up an asynchronous task and posts the messages (or at least, messages that have been marked to be posted) from that interval in the thread. The problem with this being that no matter which library I attempt to use with TARS, he is able to log in, but I have not found a successful way for him to post anything at all. TARS and these forums do not play nicely together so far, and I haven't been able to figure out a fix. I've attempted to reach out for help on the matter to a few people in the community to no avail, so it's likely this problem will not be fixed soon, barring some kind of breakthrough on my end.
[/spoiler]
Come to think of it, I agree with your position HATER. I was very shocked upon the discovery of the impact of Discord on the game, and it's not just about those who are unable to use it, like Mendel. It's also about those who aren't too active on Discord. The primary location where this game is taking place are the forums. Discord is diverting attention and making it harder to follow the train of thought. Some people will constantly be active on Discord and will talk endlessly, thereby getting more information than others. Perhaps guys, we could use the forums as the only source of actual player credibility. The problem is that a bandwagon can be decided in the heat of the moment on Discord and then applied on the forums where nobody will have an idea what it's about.

I wouldn't go as far as actually prohibiting interaction outside of the forums - obviously we need PMs. They're a standard part of all mafia/werewolf games. But steps need to be taken in the future to ensure that the old spirit of mafia is maintained and discussion takes place here where it belongs. I'd keep the same rules as changing them mid game would be upsetting for most players. Do we need anti-Discord regulation in the future? Perhaps we could create unofficial guidelines and customs which will ensure that everybody sees everything, rather then enforcing strict rules.

Mon May 28, 2018 1:36 am Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#325 (ISO #15)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
Katika VS wrote:
Cruxell, if I may ask: What spurs the sudden boom in your activity? You were basically MIA for round one, but now you're ~shudders~ basically trying to replace Ultor. What gives?
Reporting for duty, commander!
I was very much active during round one, in fact I had six posts which is twice more then you did. So, if I may ask you, what's causing you to be inactive?
Mendel wrote:
If you want to make case of Lawliet buddying Patrick from two votes on R1, the data supports that. Barely.

BUt I would love to see a proper case made why Patrick and Lawliet are in the mafia together, because I am not seeing it. There may be something posted R1 that I missed because it has been come up, but I suspect it is buried in that part of the discord that I didn't get a chance to read. If that's the case, could someone summarize for me? Please? (Preferably someone who is currently voting on this, but I'll take any summary really?)

Just read this post or this imgur link.
They're clearly teaming up, protecting one another and now that attention has been brought on Patrick the Trainee, they're employing other mafias to do their bidding for them. I can't yet say with absolute certainty who they have commanded to step up, but I am starting to draw parallels and linguistically analyze the posts of some players. You need to broaden your vision to outside of the box to realize the vice ways of mafia.

Mon May 28, 2018 9:28 am Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#363 (ISO #16)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
Although Werty's accusation of me initially made him look innocent in my eyes, I can't trust him after the last post. First he says that he trusts Romeo, and then he says that Romeo isn't playing like a village member should. This is frankly beyond my comprehension, I think that what he's trying to do is simply create discord so that we would forget about our objectives and lose faith in Romeo. Sadly, now Mendel is following Werty too.

Guys, you need to understand this: Romeo is 100% trustworthy. He knows what he's doing. If he needs help, he'll ask for help. The reason why he is not disclosing information is because it could compromise him or others. Just claim to him, and let him process the game data. Don't try to do his job.

Frankly, the next person who goes against Romeo should just be lynched right after Lawliet.

Mon May 28, 2018 6:19 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#398 (ISO #17)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
At this point, Katika is a confirmed townie, at least in my eyes. Smart of you to patiently wait, Katika. A very bad play from the mafia team, this shows a deep lack of communication.

It is crucial that we continue supporting Romeo. Guys, he may have reasons why he doesn't wish to disclose the information which he has.

I really don't know what to think about Patrick. Before, I wanted to start a bandwagon on him as soon as Lawliet flips Medic, but now I feel like he has become more trustworthy. When the voting situation was 3 on me (including Patrick) and 3 on Lawliet, with me being the expected LHLV, Patrick changed his vote. This made it 4 for Lawliet and 2 for me, as shown in the spoiler below. He could've decided that he needs to look more innocent by voting Lawliet, but I highly doubt he would've risked that in such a delicate moment. The only plausible explanation in which he is mafia is that he knew that the second informant would come forward, and Lawliet was unwilling to disclose Mystic's person C. To be honest, right now I'd say that voting for Patrick would be a bad idea. He should not be our top priority target.
Spoiler: show
Code:
Cruxell - 2 - Wertydoo, Numble
Lawliet - 4 - Cruxell, Romeo, Mendel, Patrick
Mendel - 1 - Blaze

Expected LHLV: Lawliet
No vote - 7 - JTc, Numble, Lawliet, Styx, Katika VS, Dangan, Emziek


Werty has a pretty weird style of playing to be honest. We must either trust that Romeo is village, or not trust him at all. We can't trust him and suggest that we don't listen to him. And if we don't trust him, we must lynch him. It's as simple as that. I have my magic stick out but am not picking up any penis vibes. He was the eight person to vote for Lawliet, but we've still got 13 players alive, and some are even voting for other people or are active and haven't voted Lawliet. I don't know. We'll have to keep a close eye on Werty.

Now, we must be aiming for those who are still inactive. Kudos to you for joining the game by replacing Thierry, Dangan, but you gotta step up. Note that Dangan was the fifth to vote on Lawliet.

I guess that Romeo and the results of the following round change will bring valuable information to us. The current round is pretty straightforward. Good luck, village.

Mon May 28, 2018 10:27 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#405 (ISO #18)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R2 ends 8 PM EDT Tuesday
Spoiler: show
wertydoo wrote:
Cruxell wrote:
At this point, Katika is a confirmed townie, at least in my eyes. Smart of you to patiently wait, Katika. A very bad play from the mafia team, this shows a deep lack of communication.

It is crucial that we continue supporting Romeo. Guys, he may have reasons why he doesn't wish to disclose the information which he has.

I really don't know what to think about Patrick. Before, I wanted to start a bandwagon on him as soon as Lawliet flips Medic, but now I feel like he has become more trustworthy. When the voting situation was 3 on me (including Patrick) and 3 on Lawliet, with me being the expected LHLV, Patrick changed his vote. This made it 4 for Lawliet and 2 for me, as shown in the spoiler below. He could've decided that he needs to look more innocent by voting Lawliet, but I highly doubt he would've risked that in such a delicate moment. The only plausible explanation in which he is mafia is that he knew that the second informant would come forward, and Lawliet was unwilling to disclose Mystic's person C. To be honest, right now I'd say that voting for Patrick would be a bad idea. He should not be our top priority target.[spoiler]
Code:
Cruxell - 2 - Wertydoo, Numble
Lawliet - 4 - Cruxell, Romeo, Mendel, Patrick
Mendel - 1 - Blaze

Expected LHLV: Lawliet
No vote - 7 - JTc, Numble, Lawliet, Styx, Katika VS, Dangan, Emziek


Werty has a pretty weird style of playing to be honest. We must either trust that Romeo is village, or not trust him at all. We can't trust him and suggest that we don't listen to him. And if we don't trust him, we must lynch him. It's as simple as that. I have my magic stick out but am not picking up any penis vibes. He was the eight person to vote for Lawliet, but we've still got 13 players alive, and some are even voting for other people or are active and haven't voted Lawliet. I don't know. We'll have to keep a close eye on Werty.

Now, we must be aiming for those who are still inactive. Kudos to you for joining the game by replacing Thierry, Dangan, but you gotta step up. Note that Dangan was the fifth to vote on Lawliet.

I guess that Romeo and the results of the following round change will bring valuable information to us. The current round is pretty straightforward. Good luck, village.


If Lawliet flips Mafia, I believe that Cruxell should be the next lynch. Patrick and I have both laid out strong arguments toward the scummy behavior of this dude and in those instances Cruxell has poorly attempted to turn our words into suspicion toward us. Keep an eye on me? I've been among the most pro-village players in this game. Your desperate attempts to turn the village against us for playing pro-village only adds to your scummyness.
I refer people back to my first wall of text in this round to find all the evidence they need. I wouldn't be surprised if both Cruxell and Lawliet were partners.

Moving on. I decided that I'm not going to apologize. I stand by my attitude toward Romeo. We tried to explain ourselves to him repeatedly and were met with accusations and further trolling. Mafia is a game of information. To keep information to yourself is inherently scummy. You being our confirmed villager put the fate of the village in dangerous hands. I cannot tell you how easy it would have been for me to convince people to move back to Cruxell with the little amount of information you chose to provide. And since you freely admit that you are somewhat more inexperienced than others, it BAFFLES me that you chose to ignore both Patrick, Mendel, and I; people who have been playing mafia for YEARS. The only reason we are in a strong position now is Katika and I for one give all credit to her. I think you can be a cool person to play with in the future if you learn from this experience but I have to say, your attitude this round has been egotistical, immature, and completely anti-village.
[/spoiler]
Honestly, if you don't fix your behavior and stop playing detrimentally to the village we're gonna have to lynch you. At this point it's hard for me to determine what kind of a playstyle you're pursuing but it doesn't seem right. Even if you were village your posts make no sense. I reckon just like you can not make sense as a village it makes sense that you could be mafia and not make sense which makes sense. Perhaps all this confusion in your writing is due to you purposely trying to appear non-scummy.

It's possible that you're the SK. You seem to contradict most other players and yourself, so not likely mafia. You also pursue your own ideations and purposes and don't join bandwagons. Scummy in my opinion.

But the worst of all is how you continuously continue to discredit Romeo and make him appear less credible to the village. What we need to do right now is form a round circle type of thingy where Romeo is the first among equals. We need to rally around him and elect him our leader and president of the Village Federation.

Mon May 28, 2018 11:59 pm Profile Send private message

Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2015 7:14 pm
#559 (ISO #19)  Re: Mafia XXXXI: Defibrilation (Redux) R3 ends 8 PM EDT Wednesday
HATER wrote:

-Mafia and SK will kill village players until the game reaches a 1 SK 1 maf 1 villager situation, at which point the SK will concede a victory to the mafia team, leaving mafia at parity with village, thus winning the game.

Ergo, I am calling the game in favor of the mafia team.


I get the logic behind this, but why would the SK concede the victory to the mafia? Can't he stab the last remaining mafia?
HATER wrote:
I See You Award: The SK and Mafia teams, who peeked each other simultaneously R2 and decided to work together.

Were they told that they were peeked by the other party, or did they just decide to tell the other person that they peeked them? Quite an interesting plot twist tbh.

Kudos to Mystic for his excellent strategy! I thought that there was a possibility that he would leave out player B, instead only claim to player A. As it turns out, he claimed to both plus another player. Both A and B being mafia sort of turned to our advantage.

Romeo, might I ask who all claimed doctor to you? You said there were three claims, so I reckon it must've been me, Emziek and Mendel. Also who all protected Katika when she was overdosed? All 3 doc/med roles or just 2?

Sat Jun 02, 2018 12:09 pm Profile Send private message
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group.
Designed by STSoftware for PTF.